Baking pies at high-altitude can be tricky, but I have some tips to help along the way to the perfect high-altitude pies every time! I know a lot of folks are getting ready to bake some pies this week, and no one has time for a pie disaster- let me show you how you can ensure your pies turn out perfectly for the holiday.
How to Adapt Sea-Level Pie Recipes for High-Altitude
If you’re looking at a pie recipe online, on TV, or on social media, it’s very likely that it was developed at sea-level. I find that with just a few tweaks and things to note, you can adapt the recipe easily to work at higher-altitudes. Here are some areas to focus on when making a pie recipe:
- Take your time making the crust. The hydration in a flaky pie crust is always important, but at altitude I find that sometimes a classic pie crust can be slightly under-hydrated. You want to ensure that your crust comes together completely without dry pockets of flour remaining, and you may find you need an additional 1-2 tsp. of water in the recipe.
- Work your dough together properly: Working a flakey pie dough together can be tricky because you want to keep the butter from melting, but you also want to work the dough together completely. Don’t be afraid to pop the whole bowl into the fridge or freezer for 15 minutes if you feel the butter is getting too soft before you can fully work the dough together. I like to turn the dough out onto a clean surface once it’s a shaggy dough, and then gently knead it together before using a bench scraper to help fold the dough onto itself several times to fully bring it together. This method also helps create even more layers in the dough.
- Always chill your crusts before baking: Crusts can often slump or shrink a bit more in high-altitude settings, so taking the extra time to form your crust into your pan and then freeze it completely for 30-45 minutes can make a big difference in how much it shrinks when you bake the crust or the full pie. I always freeze a flakey crust or tart crust completely before baking, although you do not normally need to do this for cookie-based crusts.
- For high-sugar pies, reduce the sugar by about 10%. Pecan pies, brownie pies, and chess pies often rely heavily on multiple forms of sugar to create the perfect texture. Since water evaporates more quickly at altitude, this can cause the sugar to heat more quickly in a pie as it bakes, which can cause a bubbling sugary mess. I like to adjust down the sugar in a recipe slightly to help accomodate this.
- Don’t be afraid to tent your pies with foil if they are browning too quickly before the filling sets. This can happen because the liquid evaporation can start to occur before thickening agents have activated in the bake time. Typically you want to check doneness by the visual cues in a recipe, and in fact that can be an important factor in the recipe that you choose.
- Do not over-beat meringues. Baked meringues benefit from under-whipping at altitude. This means that in a recipe that calls for stiff peaks, you want to beat the meringue until it’s just shy of stiff peaks, or even into the soft peak stage. Overbeating can cause a meringue that collapses or weeps more easily in baking and storing.
- Cook stovetop pie fillings thoroughly, again you may find that thickening agents need a little extra time even with stovetop pudding filling recipes, so be sure to give the filling an extra 30 seconds to 1 minute of cook time while whisking constantly to ensure that your cornstarch or eggs are fully activated.



Working with High-Altitude Pie Recipes
Of course, the easiest option for your holiday pies is to work with recipes that were developed and tested at high-altitude already. Here are some of my favorite pie recipes for Thanksgiving and beyond. These are recipes that I make most years for Thanksgiving, and that I know will work beautifully for your holiday table:
Classic High-Altitude Pumpkin Pie




Tools for High-Altitude Pie Baking
Here’s a quick rundown of some of my favorite tools for making pies at high-altitude:
- Pie plates that bake evenly and have nice edges to hold up your crust as it bakes. These USA Pan ones are my go-to.
- A metal rolling pin is my favorite tool for keeping the dough cool and for ease of use when rolling out pie crusts.
- Kitchen shears to cut off excess pie crust easily.
- Small mesh shaker to easily dust powdered sugar on top of pies before serving.
- A kitchen torch to brûlée the tops of pies before serving.
- Half-sheet pans to help transfer pies in and out of the oven more easily and without spilling filling into your oven.
Have the best holiday ever baking pies for your family- enjoy!

Hello and welcome! My name is Nicole, and Dough-eyed is a food blog for people who want to bake for their family and friends in high-altitude areas. Think of me as a friendly voice there with you in the kitchen, here to give you confidence when you’re baking, and to help you with the struggles of baking at high-altitude. Come back every week for new recipes, tips, and advice on high-altitude baking!

Leave a Reply